How to Make Homemade Eggnog: Recipe from Beets ‘n Bones

Avoid chemicals and fake flavorings in store bought eggnog this season — make home made eggnog with real food ingredients

Valeria, author of the blog Beets ‘n Bones, put together this whole food eggnog recipe for her family.  After reading the labels of prepared eggnog available in stores, which contain industrial fillers and emulsifiers such as carageenan, as well as food coloring and high fructose corn syrup, Valeria did some research and found traditional recipes for this rich wintertime treat. She gives the following advice, as well as a lot of notes on how to make this recipe on her blog:

I would only recommend this recipe if you are able to get local farmed eggs from a source you can trust. Raw eggs have amazing health benefits and using them in an eggnog is an easy way to get your kids to eat them. The recipes from 150 years ago recommended using milk, as opposed to cream, because whole milk, especially from Jersey cows (the brown ones), naturally has a ton of cream in it. The milk I get from Amish Healthy Foods sometimes is as much as one third cream. I still add extra cream because I love it.

We couldn’t agree with Valeria more.  In her original blog post, she talks a lot about where she buys her eggs and dairy, and how she chooses who to buy from.  It’s worth the extra cost and effort to seek out the highest quality, highest welfare eggs and dairy.

 

Traditional eggnog recipe made with real whole food ingredients

Ingredients

  • 6 egg yolks from pastured chickens
  • ¼ cup raw cane sugar, or maple syrup
  • A pinch of fine sea salt
  • 2 teaspoons vanilla syrup
  • 1.5 cup raw cream
  • ½ cup raw milk
  • 2 tablespoons rum or brandy (optional)
  • Freshly grated nutmeg to taste

home made eggnog from scratch

Method

  1. Whisk egg yolks with a stand mixer until they change color to pale yellow, 10 minutes or so.
  2. Add sugar, salt and vanilla, and whisk until sugar is incorporated.
  3. Add cream, milk, rum and nutmeg and whisk until everything is smooth and creamy.
  4. Sprinkle more nutmeg on top right before serving.

read Valeria’s full original recipe here

Learn more

Check out Valeria’s blog, dedicated to bringing back whole food traditional recipes and methods: Beets ‘n Bones.

Read the Ethical Foods buying guides for advice on choosing humane, healthy eggs and dairy.

Check out Nina Planck’s book on traditional foods:Real Food: What to Eat and Why

Amazon.com Filters For Healthy Indoor Air

In The Kitchen

The Best Grass-fed Lamb Burger Recipe

This easy to make spiced lamb burger recipe can be enjoyed in pita, on sesame buns or converted into small meat balls for small plate… Read more
how to make pumpkin orange marmalade or jam

Easy Fresh Pumpkin Orange Marmalade Recipe

Marmelade à la citrouille et à l’orange. Here’s a lovely recipe for a fresh pumpkin jam that’s earthy, bright and versatile. The flavor and color will… Read more
Vegan basil pesto recipe

Summer Is Basil Season: Try This Easy Vegan Pesto Recipe

It’s summer, which means basil season is in full swing. Either you are harvesting ample, fragrant basil from your herb garden, getting bunches of it… Read more
sustainable food juicing

Juice Cleanse: Starting the New Year Right

Juicing is an excellent way to detox from the excesses of the holiday season and start the new year healthy and light. January is the… Read more

Drink Tulsi Tea and Ward Off the Flu

Tulsi, also known as Holy Basil, is a remarkably delicious way to ease stress and boost your immune system this flu season. Many of you… Read more
How to plan a sustainable, organic, and local holiday dinner

How To Plan An Eco Friendly Holiday Feast

Our top six tips for a healthy, sustainable and locally sourced holiday dinner. Save money, avoid waste and enjoy a wholesome, humane feast. Read more

Death By Ratatouille: Are You Allergic To Nightshades?

Nightshade vegetables may be secretly making you sick Okay, Death may be a bit extreme here, but you would be surprised how many people have… Read more
Recipe High Quality Chicken Stock

How to Make High Quality Chicken Stock

A chicken stock recipe for serious eaters and serious cooks. Rich in flavor and high in nutrition, this stock will make everything you cook unmistakably better.… Read more